Which Sandals in Jamaica Is the Best? Here’s How to Choose
Ever wondered why some couples come back from Jamaica looking like they’ve discovered the secret to eternal honeymoon bliss? After visiting Sandals Montego Bay and Royal Caribbean myself—and with Dunn’s River on my list for this summer—I get why couples struggle to choose. Each resort has its own personality, and what feels like paradise for one couple might not be the right fit for another. As someone who’s helped several couples find their perfect paradise, I can tell you it’s not just the Caribbean sun working its magic – it’s knowing which Sandals Resort matches your romance style.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. Teach Travel Discover is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program as well as other affiliate programs. These are designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites at no extra cost to you. Please see our Privacy Policy for more details.
Think of Sandals Resorts as a love language in hotel form. Some bring the energy with nonstop beachfront parties and adventure, while others are all about private butlers and quiet, toes-in-the-sand luxury. After years of matching couples with their perfect resorts, I’ve cracked the code on which one will make your trip unforgettable. Let’s break it down.
Why Sandals Resorts Are Worth It for Couples
Picture this: you and your sweetie, hand-in-hand on a pristine Jamaican beach, sipping tropical cocktails while the Caribbean sun paints the sky in gorgeous oranges and pinks. That’s what Sandals Resorts in Jamaica does best – they turn regular vacations into romantic fairytales.
I’ve seen tons of loved-up couples absolutely MELT over the VIP treatment at these all-inclusive havens. Each resort has its own personality (kind of like relationships, right?), but they all nail that perfect mix of luxury and laid-back vibes that makes romance bloom.
Whether you’re sprawled out on South Coast’s endless private beach or watching the sunset from Royal Caribbean’s intimate shoreline, these resorts know how to set the mood. The best part? You won’t have to lift a finger – everything from gourmet meals to beachfront activities comes wrapped in your stay.
Trust me, nothing kills romance faster than surprise bills or planning stress. At Sandals, your only job is to focus on each other. How’s that for relationship goals?
Which Sandals in Jamaica Is the Best? Breaking It Down
Let me tell you – each resort brings something special to the romance table. If you’re looking for intimate vibes, Royal Caribbean is your spot. It’s smaller, quieter, and the staff treats you like royalty. Plus, the fact that its almost on a private island gives it that extra touch of exclusivity (I mean, who doesn’t want that on their honeymoon?).
Want more energy and options? Sandals Ochi has four beaches, a ton of activities, and a social vibe that’s perfect if you want entertainment built into your stay. And those beachfront dinners? Worth it.
Sandals South Coast is my personal pick for couples who want a mix of romance and variety. There’s a long private beach, overwater bungalows, and plenty of space to feel like you have your own corner of paradise. The food isn’t the main event here, but between the setting and the experience, most couples don’t mind.
Most of my honeymoon clients choose based on the vibe they want:
- Montego Bay for the lively, social scene.
- Royal Caribbean for seclusion and quiet romance.
- South Coast for a balance of both.
The key is knowing what kind of trip you’re after—because no two resorts feel the same.
Which Sandals Resort Fits You? What Each One Does Best
Not all Sandals resorts feel the same, and picking the right one is the difference between “best trip ever” and “why are we walking a mile to the beach?” Here’s what you need to know:
Montego Bay – If you want true beachfront luxury, this is it. Unlike some resorts where the beach is an afterthought, here you’re literally steps from the sand everywhere you go—no long treks, no waiting, just straight-up oceanfront vibes. The energy is high, the nightlife is buzzing, and the airport is close enough to have you sipping cocktails within an hour of landing. Just know that those planes overhead aren’t exactly whisper-quiet.
Royal Caribbean – Smaller, quieter, and all about service. The beach is smaller, but that also means fewer crowds and more privacy. The real highlight? The private island, giving you an even more exclusive escape. If you want a resort that feels intimate and personal, this is your spot.
South Coast – My personal go-to for couples who want balance. The private beach stretches forever, the waterfront rooms put you right on the ocean, and it’s got just the right mix of relaxation and activities. If you don’t want to pick between seclusion and fun, this is the sweet spot.
How Sandals Resorts in Jamaica Compare
Ochi – This resort is massive—it’s like four resorts in one. Whether you’re in the mood for a lively scene or a tucked-away retreat, you’ll find it here. Just keep in mind, the shuttle system can be a pain (because nothing kills the vibe like waiting for a ride), but the variety of experiences makes up for it.
Let’s break down what really matters when choosing your Sandals resort:
Beaches
If a secluded, private beach is a must, South Coast wins—it’s massive, untouched, and only for guests. On the other hand, Negril sits on Seven Mile Beach, which is iconic but shared with the public. That means lively energy, local vendors, and more activity. If you want the best of both worlds, Montego Bay is one of the few truly oceanfront resorts, where the beach is right outside your door—no long walks required.
Food & Dining
Sandals Dunn’s River is raising the bar on food. The new restaurant concepts bring fresher, more elevated menus, making it the top choice for foodies. Royal Caribbean is smaller, so there are fewer options, but the service makes up for it—expect staff who remember your name, your order, and maybe even your favorite dessert. If you’re looking for variety, Ochi has the most restaurants out of all Sandals resorts, though you’ll need to shuttle between them.
Nightlife & Entertainment
If you want a party vibe, Montego Bay and Ochi are your best bets. Montego Bay keeps the energy high with its central location and lively beachfront bars, while Ochi’s multiple sections let you bounce between party mode and quiet escapes. South Coast and Royal Caribbean? Definitely on the quieter side, perfect for couples who want romance without the background noise.
Service & Atmosphere
If personalized service and intimate vibes are what you’re after, Royal Caribbean and South Coast deliver. Their smaller size means the staff gets to know you quickly—by day two, they’ll already have your favorite drink waiting. Dunn’s River is also stepping up in this area with a more upscale feel, while Ochi and Montego Bay tend to be more fast-paced and social.
The Bottom Line
- Best for privacy & romance: Royal Caribbean, South Coast
- Best for nonstop entertainment: Montego Bay, Ochi
- Best beach setup: South Coast (private), Montego Bay (steps away), Negril (famous but public)
- Best food: Dunn’s River (new & elevated), Ochi (most variety), Royal Caribbean (small but top-tier service)
The key is choosing based on what matters most to you. Love quiet luxury? Stick to the smaller resorts. Want high energy? Go big with Montego Bay or Ochi. Either way, you’re getting an all-inclusive escape made for couples—just pick the right one for your style.
Next-Level Perks: The Luxury Extras That Matter
Sandals knows how to do luxury, especially for honeymooners. From the second you step into your Love Nest Suite—with butler service and ocean views—you’ll feel like you’re in your own private escape.
Honeymoon perks? Expect breakfast in bed, romantic bubble baths with flower petals, and champagne on ice waiting in your room. And those private candlelit beach dinners? They’re as stunning in real life as they are in the photos.
Want to take it up a notch? A couples massage at Red Lane Spa is a must—especially at sunset. Or, book a private sunset cruise where it’s just you two, the open water, and a bottle of champagne.
Thinking about a wedding? Sandals’ wedding teams handle it all—from the flowers to the cake—so you don’t have to stress over the details. Saying “I do” with your toes in the sand? That’s next-level romance.
What Couples Really Think: Honest Sandals Reviews
Let me spill the tea about what actual couples are saying about these dreamy spots (because who better to trust than couples who’ve been there, right?).
Our Most Positive Reviews
South Coast gets rave reviews for its secluded, private beach and peaceful atmosphere. Couples who’ve stayed at multiple Sandals resorts say this one feels the most like a true getaway. One couple even told me they’ve stayed at every Sandals in Jamaica, but South Coast stole their hearts.
Royal Caribbean is a favorite for honeymooners who want privacy without the crowds. The intimate size means no fighting for beach chairs or dinner reservations, which is a win. The one downside? Some couples feel the price doesn’t quite match the experience, but if personalized service and a quieter atmosphere matter more than flashy amenities, it’s a solid choice.
Our Least Recommended
Ochi gets mixed feedback. Couples love the variety—four beaches, tons of restaurants, and activities for days—but the shuttle system is a hassle, and some feel like they’re being pulled into more activities than they actually want. If you’re social and love options, it works. If you’re looking for pure relaxation, it might be too much.
Most Overrated
Montego Bay? It depends on what kind of traveler you are. Some couples love the high-energy vibe, but others say the airport noise kills the romance. A few have even compared it to a budget cruise experience. If you’re into partying and don’t mind planes overhead, it still has its perks—but if you’re looking for peace and quiet, this isn’t your spot.
For me personally, it was underwhelming. Considering it was the first Sandals, it feels “old” and can definitely be updated. The food was underwhelming, to say the least and we found ourselves…bored. I will say that having the beach steps away is its saving grace.
Which Sandals Resort Is Best for Your Destination Wedding
Planning to say “I do” in paradise? Not all Sandals resorts are created equal when it comes to weddings. Here’s how they stack up:
Best for Intimate Weddings: Sandals Royal Caribbean
If you want a smaller, private feel, Royal Caribbean is the way to go. The beachfront gazebo is stunning at sunset, and the smaller guest capacity means your wedding won’t feel like just another event on the schedule. The staff is incredibly attentive, making it feel like the entire resort is catering to your day.
Best for Large Weddings: Sandals Ochi
If you’re bringing a crowd, Ochi has the most venue options and plenty of space for your guests to spread out. With multiple ceremony locations, lively nightlife, and tons of dining options, it’s ideal for couples who want a big celebration with a built-in after-party.
Best for a True Beachfront Wedding: Sandals Montego Bay
Many Sandals resorts say they’re beachfront, but Montego Bay is one of the few where the sand is literally steps away from everything. If you want to walk straight from your suite onto the beach for your ceremony, this is the spot. Just be aware—it’s a livelier resort, so if total seclusion is your goal, look elsewhere.
Best for Adventurous Couples: Sandals Dunn’s River
For couples who want more than just a beach backdrop, Dunn’s River delivers. You’ll be near Jamaica’s famous waterfalls (perfect for epic wedding photos), plus the resort has water sports, catamaran cruises, and an upscale vibe.
Best for a Relaxing, All-Out Honeymoon Vibe: Sandals South Coast
If you want a wedding that rolls straight into pure honeymoon bliss, South Coast is it. The secluded, private beach, overwater chapel, and romantic waterfront suites make it feel completely removed from the outside world. If privacy and an ultra-romantic setting matter most, this is the one.
Final Word
- Small, intimate weddings? Royal Caribbean
- Big wedding with a party scene? Ochi
- Best true beachfront ceremony? Montego Bay
- Want adventure with your vows? Dunn’s River
- Looking for total romance & seclusion? South Coast
The key is choosing a resort that fits your wedding vision AND your honeymoon vibe. No two Sandals feel the same—so pick the one that gives you the wedding AND the experience you actually want.
Why Booking With a Travel Advisor Gets You More
Here’s a little secret from someone who books these places on the regular – working with a travel advisor can seriously up your romance game! We’ve got connections that could score you room upgrades, special anniversary surprises, and those hard-to-get dinner reservations at the best restaurants.
Think VIP check-in (bye-bye, long lines), welcome gifts in your room, and insider tips on the most romantic spots at each resort. Plus, we know exactly when to book for the best rates – because nothing says “I love you” like saving money for extra spa treatments!
Want the real scoop on which butler service is worth the splurge? Or which rooms ACTUALLY have the best views? That’s where we come in handy. We’ve visited these resorts ourselves and heard the good, bad, and sandy from our clients.
Pro tip: Book through an advisor during shoulder season (May or November) – you’ll get all the romance without the peak-season crowds or prices.
Final Thoughts: Which Sandals in Jamaica Is the Best for You?
Picking the right Sandals resort isn’t about finding the “best” one—it’s about finding the best one for you. Whether you’re drawn to Royal Caribbean’s quiet luxury, South Coast’s secluded beachfront, or Ochi’s endless variety, your perfect match is out there.
But here’s the thing—choosing the right resort can make or break your experience. You don’t want to end up somewhere that doesn’t match your vibe, especially for something as big as a honeymoon or destination wedding. That’s where having a travel advisor who actually knows these resorts inside and out makes all the difference.
Not sure which Sandals in Jamaica is the best for you? Let’s chat. I’ll help you skip the guesswork and find the perfect spot—so all you have to do is pack. Book a free consultation today!